The Real Reason Why Self Development Doesn’t Work

If you’ve spent any time in the self-development world, chances are you’ve wondered why self development doesn’t work… or it might (for a bit), but it just doesn’t stick!

You do the thing.
You go to the workshop, start the practice, commit to the routine.
You feel better. Clearer. Lighter. Hopeful, even.

And then… a few days or weeks later, you’re back where you started.

Same triggers.
Same patterns.
Same internal conversations.

It’s frustrating. And if you’re honest, it can feel pretty demoralising. You’d think with all the money being spent on self-development, we’d be more interested in understanding why self development doesn’t work in the way we need or want it to.

At some point you might start to wonder:

  • Am I doing it wrong?

  • Why does it work for other people but not for me?

  • Why can I see what needs to change but still can’t seem to change it?

Here’s the bit most of the self-development industry doesn’t talk about:

The problem isn’t your commitment.
It isn’t your mindset.
And it definitely isn’t that you’re “not trying hard enough.”

The real issue is that most self-development work creates temporary lifts, not lasting change.

There. I said it!

The reason why self development doesn’t work in the way we want it to, is because there’s a mismatch.

Why Feeling Better Isn’t the Same as Changing

Let’s start by saying something important:
Many self-development practices do work.

Meditation, breathwork, journaling, movement, personal development events, spiritual retreats – these can all make you feel better. Sometimes dramatically so.

You might feel calmer.
More optimistic.
More motivated.
More like yourself.

But feeling better and being different are not the same thing.

Most of these practices lift you above your default state – and when the practice stops, you naturally fall back down.

That doesn’t mean they’re useless. It just means they’re limited.

They change how you feel temporarily, not how you operate fundamentally.

And this is where most people get stuck.

The Missing Piece: Your Baseline

To understand why self development doesn’t work – or stick – you need to understand one concept:

Your baseline level of consciousness.

Your baseline is where you naturally settle when you’re not actively trying to improve your mood, regulate yourself, or “do the work.” It’s your emotional and psychological default.

Think of it like this.

Imagine the sea on a stormy day. Waves are crashing high and low. It’s chaotic, and it’s hard to tell where the actual water level is.

Now imagine the same sea on a calm day. The surface is still. You can clearly see where the water meets the harbour wall.

That calm waterline is your baseline.

You can lift yourself above it with effort – through practices, experiences, or environments – but unless the waterline itself changes, you’ll always return to it.

This is why:

  • you feel great after a retreat but flat a week later

  • you meditate daily and still feel fundamentally anxious

  • you “know better” but don’t behave differently under pressure

You’re operating from the same baseline.

Temporary Lifts vs Lasting Change

Most self-development tools are designed to help you manage your state, not change it.

They help you cope.
They help you regulate.
They help you get through the day.

But when something stressful happens – a conflict, a setback, a loss, a trigger – you don’t respond from your best day. You respond from your baseline.

That’s why people can have incredible insights, make bold plans, and genuinely believe things will be different… only to find that when life resumes, the same limitations reappear.

It’s not a lack of willpower.
It’s not laziness.
It’s not self-sabotage in the way people usually mean it.

It’s gravity.

Why Motivation Doesn’t Fix It

This is also why motivation is such a poor long-term strategy.

Motivation is a state. Baselines are structures.

You can’t motivate yourself out of a baseline that’s weighed down by unresolved emotional material.

When people say things like:

  • “I just need more discipline”

  • “I need to want it badly enough”

  • “I should be able to push through this”

They’re trying to override something structural with effort.

It doesn’t work for long. And when it fails, people tend to blame themselves.

What Actually Lowers a Baseline

So what determines your baseline in the first place?

In short: emotional weight.

Your baseline is pulled down by things like:

  • unresolved trauma

  • emotional wounds

  • chronic triggers

  • suppressed fear, anger, guilt, or shame

  • internal conflict

These don’t disappear just because you’ve had a good insight or a calming experience.

They sit in the background, quietly shaping how you perceive the world, how you interpret events, and how you respond under stress.

When they’re present, life feels heavier.
Decisions feel harder.
Change feels effortful.

And when they’re healed, something remarkable happens.

Healing Is What Raises the Baseline

Healing is not about coping better. It’s not about managing your reactions. And it’s not about learning to “be okay” with things that hurt.

Healing is what happens when:

  • something that used to trigger you no longer does

  • emotional charge dissolves

  • old patterns lose their grip

  • your nervous system stops bracing

Healing removes emotional weight. And when weight is removed, your baseline rises naturally.

This is why people who have done deep healing work often seem calmer without trying, clearer without effort, and more resilient without forcing themselves.

They’re not constantly regulating. They’re just not using up energy holding themselves together.

There’s simply less to hold.

Why You Still Dip (And Why That’s Normal)

Raising your baseline doesn’t mean you’ll never feel low again.

Life still happens.

Loss, stress, illness, relationship challenges, world events – all of these can temporarily pull your level of consciousness down.

The difference is not whether you dip, but:

  • how far you fall

  • how long you stay there

Someone with a lower baseline may be pulled into long-term anxiety or overwhelm after a difficult event. Someone with a higher baseline still feels pain – but they don’t lose themselves in it.

Resilience isn’t toughness.
It’s capacity.

The Role of the Collective (And Why You Sometimes Feel “Off”)

One more piece that often gets overlooked is the collective.

Your emotional state isn’t shaped in isolation.

Large-scale events, social tension, fear in the media, collective uncertainty – these things affect everyone. You might feel unsettled, flat, or anxious without anything personal being “wrong.”

This isn’t imaginary. It’s attunement.

The more healed you are, the less destabilising this becomes – but no one is completely immune. Again, the difference is recovery.

So Why Doesn’t Self-Development Stick?

Because most self-development:

  • lifts you temporarily

  • helps you manage symptoms

  • doesn’t change the structure underneath

And when the structure doesn’t change, neither does your life.

Lasting change doesn’t come from stacking more practices on top of the same foundation. It comes from changing the foundation.

If You Want to Go Deeper

If this resonates, the next step isn’t “trying harder.”

It’s understanding how consciousness actually works:

  • what determines your baseline

  • why it rises and falls

  • and what creates lasting change rather than temporary relief

I’ve written a deeper, foundational piece on this here:

👉 Consciousness: What It Is, Why It Changes, and How to Raise It

That page lays out the full framework — not as theory, but as something you can recognise in your own life.

Because once you understand why change hasn’t stuck, you can finally stop blaming yourself – and start doing what actually works.

Alexia Leachman
Follow me
Latest posts by Alexia Leachman (see all)